Turtleboy Investigates

The Suspicious Death Of ‘All That Remains’ Lead Guitarist Is The Internet Speculation Murder Mystery Of The Week

The Suspicious Death Of ‘All That Remains’ Lead Guitarist Is The Internet Speculation Murder Mystery Of The Week

Follow and Subscribe to Turtleboy podcasts on SoundCloud or iTunes by clicking here

Follow and like the Turtleboy Sports Returns, and Clarence Woods Emerson to keep up with the hilarious turtle rider commentary.

Want to advertise with Turtleboy? Email us at Turtleboysports@gmail.com for more information.

If you like free speech and want to support what we’re doing, feel free to donate to the Turtle fund:







Hello Turtle Riders. As you know if you follow Turtleboy we are constantly getting by Facebook for what are clearly not violations of their terms of service. Twitter has done the same, and trolls mass reported our blog to Google AdSense thousands of times, leading to demonitization. We can get by and survive, but we could really use your help. Please consider donating by hitting the PayPal button above if you’d like support free speech and what we do in the face of Silicon Valley censorship.


On October 16th, 44-year old Oli Herbert, the lead guitarist of ‘All That Remains’ was found dead in a pond abutting his property in Stafford Springs, CT, apparently drowned. This story is crazy, and has definitely left me saying, “hmmm”. And it looks like I’m definitely not the only one, as Connecticut State Police are now treating his death as suspicious.

There’s definitely a lot of dots to connect here, and it’s pretty compelling stuff. There’s a lot of speculation going on online right now, but only one theory popping up –

The now widowed wife, Beth Herbert.

There’s a lot of information bouncing around at there right now, but this is what we know for sure:

  • Oli Herbert married his wife, Beth Herbert, on August 15th, 2004. 14 years, 2 months and 1 day later, his body was found in Hydeville Pond, steps from his house.
  • Oli and Beth had been having marital problems and Oli was preparing for divorce.
  • Oli’s friends and family describe Beth as extremely jealous, controlling and volatile towards her husband.
  • Beth was close friends with Wendy Skriver, a well known stalker/groupie of Oli Herberts, who once had a very public meltdown when she felt unacknowledged at one of his shows. Her presence, and friendship with Beth, seems to permeate this case.
  • Oli and Beth’s home had recently gone into foreclosure, and Beth seemed pretty staunchly intent on the house.
  • Beth has been acting pretty fucking weird online in the month since Oli’s passing.
  • A toxicology report found anti depressants in Oli’s system – Oli was 44 years old and not known to drink, do drugs or suffer from depression. He was not seeing a doctor for depression and had no active prescriptions for anti-depressants.
  • Oli’s friends and bandmates are utterly convinced that foul play was involved, and are heavily implicating his wife. They’ve started a Facebook Page, Justice For Oli Herbert , and Oli’s widow, Beth Herbert, is not particularly pleased about it.

I don’t think anyone would be thrilled with being openly accused of having a hand in their husbands murder, though, to be fair.

Beth and Oli had a pretty tumultuous and volatile relationship, marked by jealousy and rage.


Yeah. it’s not the healthiest sign when your husband maintains a burner phone just to stay in contact with friends and family. Doesn’t make for the happiest of homes.

Beth was, by all accounts, a very jealous, insecure and controlling partner, who also would regularly use the phones she stole to threaten, harass and insult anyone she objected to her husband speaking to.

She seems nice. Huge hit at parties, I’m sure.


And in the months leading up to his death, Oli seems to have had enough, and was preparing to file for divorce –



Reportedly, much to his wife’s chagrin.



It only gets shadier from here.


Oli and Beth’s Stafford Springs home went into pre-foreclosure on or about September 13, 2018. They owed the bank $15,000 to get the house out of foreclosure, and according to his friends, Oli was planning on just cutting his losses, letting the house go, and moving on. Which may, or may not, be why he didn’t show up to court to fight the foreclosure – just about a month before his death.

What’s also pretty strange, is Beth’s close friendship with this chick, Wendy Skriver.

Wendy was described by friends and family as Oli’s “stalker”. She would often pop up at the same places as Oli, almost as if she was following him. On March 31st of 2018, at the Hard Rock Cafe Foxwoods, Wendy had a very public meltdown after feeling “ignored” by Oli, at a video release party with roughly 300 attendees, who all witnessed it. Strangely, the reportedly possessive and jealous Beth didn’t threaten, harass or assault Wendy – she struck up a close relationship, even attending Wendy’s daughter’s graduation.

Weird. There’s a whole lot of Wendy involved with this, too.  Check it out. June 27th, 2018 – roughly 3 months before Oli’s death, the couple is served notice of the bank’s intention to foreclose on their home.

About a month later, and roughly two months before his death, Beth decides to clear out the brush in the yard of their imminently foreclosing home that was obstructing a path to the pond Oli’s body was discovered in,

And look who helped.



But people do yard work all the time. Maybe less so on a house that they know the bank is coming to repossess, but who knows.

And around the same time that Beth and Wendy started doing some landscaping by the pond, something else weird and tragic happened. Beth posted two separate statuses pointing out the delicious people snacks she was feeding to her and Oli’s two dogs,


And then tragically, they died. Both of dogs. Within a week,  and a little over a month before her husband’s death.

It’s definitely strange, although, this woman may have just been having a bad month.


This is where is really gets crazy, though. A mere week before Oli’s death, Beth went and redid his will and power of attorney. And who was the notary public?

……Wendy Shriver. This was purportedly signed by Beth and Ollie at the car dealership where Wendy’s works, with 2 of Wendy’s coworkers as witnesses, one of whom cannot definitively verify if he even saw Oli that day. I’m no Scruff Mcgruff, but even I have to admit – there is something kind of weird about redoing your will at 44 years old at a car dealership a week before your death, with a woman who your inner circle refers to as your “stalker” in the middle of the contentious dissolution of your 14 year marriage.


The timing could’ve been better. Or maybe it couldn’t, depending on your opinion on what happened to Oli Herbert.


Wendy was at the scene when the police showed up, and has been by Beth’s side ever since.

Weird. Thanks for clearing that up, Wendy? Who knows. Again, seeing as these two are being publicly implicated, it’s possible that they just felt the need to address it.

But Beth sure posted some weird shit on the day of her husband’s death.




….And in it’s wake.

That’s some strange looking grief.

Here at Turtleboy we aren’t the state police, so my speculation in this is irrelevant. One thing is clear, though, this is hella shady, and the police clearly agree. I have more information to sift through than I want to cram into one blog, though – so I’m going to go ahead and call this one as a multi-part series. Stay tuned, Turtle Riders.


12 Comment(s)
  • Willie Fistegash
    November 21, 2018 at 4:32 pm

    Who fucking cares

    • Captain Trips
      Captain Trips
      November 21, 2018 at 8:44 pm

      I have to agree. The dude was most likely just a scumbag that never grew up past 14 years old. I’m surprised he didn’t still live in his mommy’s basement.

      Get a haircut, grow the fuck up, stop doing drugs, and get a real job.

      These long haired bad-attitude-faced pseudo-rock musicians now-a-days are just arrested development types trying to impress and sleep with 15 year old girls. The Jim Morrison thing is fucking over. These days you just look like posers

      • Gardenlady
        November 24, 2018 at 8:39 pm

        He didnt drink or do drugs dumbass

  • Reader
    November 21, 2018 at 3:29 pm

    Thanks Bristol Turtlechick, can’t wait for the rest of the series!

  • Hercule Poirot
    November 21, 2018 at 2:08 pm

    Motive, check. Opportunity check. While it may be circumstantial she’s so fucking guilty…

  • z
    November 21, 2018 at 1:29 pm

    What, no snide headline?
    Basically white ratchets, but it’s “Different” because it’s white people and you like the music.

    Nothing about a greasy haired Grizzly Adams who couldn’t break out of the local scene because he and the band sucked balls? Nothing to say about Stafford Springs, like “The place were hicks go to watch cars drive around in circles?”

    You know you would if the race and location were different.

    I await the next regional rapper who dies and the blog post. I doubt there will be any sympathy then.
    You went apeshit about an eldery woman blogging in the Mid-west.

    • November 21, 2018 at 1:33 pm

      Considering there’s an open police investigation, I chose to tread lightly. Relax. Diane Benjamin grinds my gears – to each their own. I hope mom puts some xanax in the turkey for you tomorrow.

    • Vito
      November 22, 2018 at 11:35 am

      You know why no snide headline you sad sack of soy? It’s because Oli was actually a nice guy. I know, met him quite a few times. Not a druggie. An actual dedicated musician. He was no slouch on his instrument and wasn’t trying to impress teenie-boppers.
      You on the other hand seem to want to defend actual degenerates. Yeah, I am calling most of these “rappers” featured on TBS shit bags.

  • randiguy2006
    Randall Guy
    November 21, 2018 at 1:24 pm


    Can you please get back to doing what you best?

    High School locker room investigations

    • November 21, 2018 at 1:33 pm

      Always nice to see you’ve stopped by, Randall.

    • Randy For Young Meat
      November 21, 2018 at 3:34 pm

      Randy’s got a hankering for little boys in locker rooms.

      NAMBLA’s probably having a meeting in Cambridge sometime soon, chomo.

    • randall guy jr.
      November 24, 2018 at 8:53 pm

      daddy, momma say where da welfare money be at? a 24 pack of astrolube and a rainbow teeshirt got delivered fo you tooday fool.

Comment on this Post


Who Are Worcester’s Top 5 DUI (OUI) Attorney’s?
Best Show Of All Time: True Detective, House Of Cards, The Wire, Sopranos, Or Breaking Bad?
I Figured Out What Happens To Tony Soprano In Final Scene But It Still Sucks; Here Are The Top 10 Funniest Scenes In Sopranos History