The Live Debate With Nathan Thompson Was As Rife With Mental Illness As We Expected, Who Won?

Well, I debated Nathan Thompson and even though I spent days watching his previous debates and felt prepared for his delusional ramblings….there is no real preparation. I’m not a scientist by any measure, but you don’t have to be to debunk the fallacious assertions Nathan threw my way. Rather than bother with refuting his tenuous grasp on scientific theory, I chose to focus on his tenuous grasp on reality. His “Global conspiracy” theory holds no water in a logical world, and characteristic of someone suffering a delusional disorder, Nathan attempts to adjust reality to fit his perspective. It doesn’t work well. At the end of the day, nobody really wins, because you can’t have a debate with him – he lives in a world left of reality, and nothing will change that – hence my strong suspicion that he is afflicted with mental illness.

Some of the highlights include:


Nathan insisting that the shadow observation Eratosthenes used to calculate the circumference of the Earth works on a flat model.

It doesn’t.


This is elementary school stuff.


Nathan claimed that ships observed sinking over the horizon was a matter of perspective, not proof of the earth’s curve.


Come on. Perspective accounts for objects appearing smaller as they move away, not dipping below the horizon.


Nathan claimed I was “triggered” and “melting”.

His word salad is entirely headache inducing. I had to stop myself from correcting him every time he tried to invoke the second law of thermodynamics incorrectly – there was no point. He doesn’t understand the concept of an “isolated system”.

Nathan claimed to have seen God, but if he put it into words, he’d be discrediting God.

Delusional. Disorder.


Nathan Could Not Actually Answer One Question Directly.


Nathan claimed the moon’s light is “septic”, and we use it to make beef jerky.

You can’t make this shit up.


Anyway, you can see the full debate here, and vote on it below. The moderators did score me the winner, but in all fairness, Nathan did all the legwork for me, I spent more time incredulous and baffled than even I expect. The official scores are below the video.


Each category begins at 22.

Bristol TC

Argumentation: 12 (max 30)

Refutation: 23 (max 30)

Structure: 18 (max 29)

Presentation: 22 (max 30)

Civility: 2 (max 25)

TOTAL SCORE: 77 (max 144)

Notes: Bristol did not maintain civility. She cursed a lot. Her case that Nathan is simply mentally ill and his theories are not logic or fact based and do not line up with observable nature was strong. She poked holes in Nathan’s rule of observation by pointing out not observing God – and his response helped prove her case for mental illness.


Nathan Thompson

Argumentation: 19 (max 30)

Refutation: 8 – did not answer questions directly, word salad (max 30)

Structure: 25 (max 29)

Presentation: 8 (max 30)

Civility: 10 (max 25)

-2 points for being late

TOTAL SCORE: 60 (max 144)

Nathan was not able to directly answer questions. He used a lot of made up terms and didn’t correctly cite scientific laws. He was condescending and rude, and his argument was disjointed and not based in observable nature. Nathan could not make a strong argument for a global conspiracy. Nathan misquoted Neil Tyson Degrasse and contradicted himself frequently. Nathan’s responses helped strengthen Bristol’s case that he may be suffering from mental illness. Nathan lost points for being 20 minutes late.




16 Comment(s)
  • Loki and Jabroni Show
    May 1, 2019 at 9:44 am

    Nathan has many issues, one of them is being unable to directly answer questions. He repeats and regurgitates his memorized garbage and absolutely refuses to accept when he is proven wrong.
    He employed these same tactics on our podcast in November 2018, and does so in every “debate” he does.
    That, and after spewing his filth for an extended period of time, he outright DEMANDS you “prove curvature, GO!”

    He’s a sociopathic, narcissistic CUNT!!!


  • Sarah
    April 29, 2019 at 9:43 pm

    I did notice that when he is triggered that he immediately responds with calling the other person as triggered. And by the emotion when he did that that he was very much triggered.

    He learns responses to situations & questions off by heart. Sometimes he will go into a spiel unrelated to anything because it comes after the previous learnt response. He uses that memory learning technique of bouncing the golf ball while repeating phrases to himself. This is why whenever you ask a question not on his script he will just revert to one of his learnt responses even if it has nothing to do with the current situation

    Also his abusiveness could not be contained when he started with the sexist remarks about you melting. This is an old sexist remark about women not being able to have in depth conversations with men. In other videos we get an insight into his girlfriend’s letter/message call for help and how he mentally abuses her in to a fetal position crying and then whips out his ding dong and slaps her on the face with it demanding her to suck it.

  • Ray Patriarca
    A matter of perception
    April 28, 2019 at 9:28 am

    I understand Nathan. He mentioned that things looking smaller are based on perception. That’s probably the same excuse he uses with the ladies when they giggle about his little dick?
    Makes sense now !

  • O'Leary
    April 28, 2019 at 5:19 am

    You were right. His science is wrong but you used profanity and spoke over him and attacked him. In my eyes he won! He followed the rules you didn’t.

    He’s wrong you are right bit you got ghetto not him!

  • dowen0895
    Dick Scratcher
    April 27, 2019 at 2:52 pm

    No, no, no, no!! He said sunlight was good for making beef jerky.

    He said moonlight caused sepsis and was “measurably cold” which meant that it couldn’t be reflected sunlight. – without doubt the stupidest thing I have ever heard anyone say.

    Not only that, everyone who listened to that sentence is a little bit stupider for having heard it.

  • dowen0895
    Dick Scratcher
    April 27, 2019 at 2:15 pm

    No, no, no!! He said sunlight was good for making beef jerky.

    He said moonlight caused sepsis and was “measurably cold” which meant that it couldn’t be reflected sunlight. – without doubt the stupidest thing I have ever heard anyone say.

    Not only that, everyone who listened to that sentence is a little bit stupider for having heard it.

  • WPWP
    April 27, 2019 at 1:00 pm

    If the earth was flat, wouldn’t “the edge” be one of the most popular tourist attractions?

    • dowen0895
      Dick Scratcher
      April 27, 2019 at 2:06 pm

      As well as being a popular U2 guitarist?

  • Illhans goat smelling queefs
    April 27, 2019 at 12:02 pm

    So there is a judge booty….and a ‘Pete bootyjudge’? Coincidence? I think not!

    Also; drumroll please. “Zum peeple did zumthing “????

  • dowen0895
    Dick Scratcher
    April 27, 2019 at 9:04 am

    Well, that was a painful listen.
    The guy is certifiably, stark, staring mad.

    I was reminded of the janitor in Scrubs saying “I don’t believe in the moon. I think it’s the back of the sun.”

  • SammyC
    April 27, 2019 at 8:57 am

    Never argue with an idiot, they drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.

  • Judge dread
    April 27, 2019 at 7:14 am

    This is amazing. I always want to ask a flat earther (who most if not all of them use gps satellites to guide them via Apple maps, waze, etc) if the earth is flat why do we have such a thing as geosynchronous orbit for gps satellites and telecommunications satellites?

    Why don’t these flat earther idiots talk to the war planners at the pentagon on how flat the earth is and how fake their recon satellites are.

    Someone needs to take an aluminum baseball bat and rearrange this chode’s teeth. Great job Bristol.

    • Crispy C
      April 27, 2019 at 11:07 am

      I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. Smack a fucktard across the face with a 2×4 and it truly will help make them better. Conspiracy theorists are at the top of the list because they aren’t mentally ill, they are just being a fucktard for attention and they KNOW they are wrong. They just enjoy the attention of being different.

  • Hart Ford
    April 27, 2019 at 6:44 am

    Does this nitwit drive on the same roads as we do? ( for that matter does Turtlechick?)
    God help us all. Reopen Danvers State!

  • Color commentary
    April 27, 2019 at 2:35 am

    They both eat crayons with the only difference being she is a Crayola girl and Nate subsists on those freebie 4-packs they give the kids with the fun placemats at IHOP.

    • Bristol Turtlechick
      April 27, 2019 at 12:38 pm

      Actually I sustain myself on thr hurt feelings of my enemies and paste.
      When you could hear Nathan just breaking when he said, “my parents don’t like me,” my goal was accomplished.

Comment on this Post


This Truck Driver Was Really, Really Pissed About The 65 Car Accident Pile Up On 290 In Worcester.
Chinese Guy Jumps Seven Floors To His Death To Get Out Of Shopping With Girlfriend
South African Dude Who Pretended To Sign Language Obama’s Nelson Mandela Speech Is Apparently An Insane Murdering Rapist?