Bone Ride

Better Hot Dogs – Coney Island vs. Hot Dog Annie’s?

Want to have your business advert seen by over 500,000 people per month? Email us at for more information, and check out our website about types of advertising we offer.

Follow us on Twitter and like us on Facebook

Check out our stuff on GoLocalWorcester


Who makes better hot dogs? Coney Island or Hot Dog Annie’s? GFQ. We tossed that question up on the Facebook machine and got 5 million responses. Tensions were high. Clearly we had to settle this with a good ol’ fashioned dog-off.

First we went to Hot Dog Annie’s. The biggest downside to Annie’s is the fact that it’s in Leicester. Some towns have a useful purpose. Millbury is on the highway and it leads to other useful places, like Providence. But Leicester? That’s the gateway to Spencer. Going into Leicester involves driving behind some moron on Route 9 and then finding an even bigger moron to drive behind on the way home.

Anyway, when you finally get there you’re basically in the middle of nowhere.


The seating is all outside too:


Inside is basically a shack, and every time I go inside there in the summer I feel bad for the poor girls working behind the counter. Because on top of the fact that there’s obviously no AC, it’s small and there’s a piping hot grill in front of them:


Anyway, I get my dogs the only respectable way you can – with mustard and relish. Only a savage puts ketchup on a hot dog. A lot of people getting the chili dog here, but we’re trying to compare them to Coney Island dogs so we have to get the same crap on our dogs at both places.



A major difference between the two places are the buns. Annie’s grills the buns:


And one of the things that sucks about both places is……where’s the beef??

It’s like the Regatta of hot dogs. Is it really that hard to find a slightly bigger hot dog? Is that gonna tear into their profit margins or something? Come on Annie, you’re better than that.

After smashing down those twins it was time to go down to Southbridge St for a couple Coney Island dogs. First of all, how would you get from Annie’s to Coney Island? That’s what I mean by Leicester being a terrible town to travel to. You go out there and then you literally have to retrace your steps to go anywhere else except Whitco. Pain in the ass of a drive right there.

Eventually we ended up down on Southbridge St:


One of the cool things about Coney Island of course is the classic, authentic Worcester feel inside.



Coney Island is famous for it’s wooden benches with shit carved into it.



Shannon and Jeff 4-eva. I’m sure that worked out. After all, on Southbridge Street carving your names into a wooden bench is what they call a “commitment ceremony.”


Another difference between the two is the fact that they serve booze. Also, it’s a great place to read the paper, if you’re a middle-aged grizzled dude who still reads the paper.


Coney Island is basically a hot dog factor.


A major difference between the dogs at Coney Island and Annie’s, is that they put the mustard on the side of the bun, so you don’t even notice it’s there at first.


Yea, sorry Coney Island, I like my dogs SMOTHERED in cheap yellow mustard.And like I said before, they don’t toast the buns at Coney Island


For whatever reason I went into this place under the impression that there dogs had more beef to them. I dunno, you tell me which has more girth? Coney Island


or Hot Dog Annie’s


Looks like a tie to me.

I dunno, I like both these places, but you really need to order like six or seven of them to feel like you’re a real American. I feel like if one of these places invested in bigger dogs they could completely drive the other one out of business. And how much would that really cost? What do they pay, 12 cents per unit? Seems like a worthy investment.

So which one is better? Let’s look at the pros and cons of each:

Hot Dog Annie’s. Pros: You get to eat outside, the buns are toasted and buttered, they have superior mustard to dog ratio, and you’re in an isolated, quiet area. Cons: You gotta drive to Leicester, if the weather’s not great you have to eat in your car like a loser, and you could be attacked by a bear.

Coney Island. Pros: You get to eat in a controlled environment, you can get drunk, and you can declare your love for the stripper you just met at Hurricane Betty’s by carving your names into the seats. Cons: There’s no outdoor seating, the buns aren’t toasted, the mustard is hidden, and the Kelley Square day shift vagrant might hassle you on the way out.

At the end of the day I gotta go with Hot Dog Annie’s. It’s all about the buns and the mustard. Am I right or am I right?

Want to have your business advert seen by over 500,000 people per month? Email us at for more information, and check out our website about types of advertising we offer.

Follow us on Twitter and like us on Facebook

Check out our stuff on GoLocalWorcester

39 Comment(s)
  • KMc
    April 4, 2015 at 6:11 pm

    Coney Island had a health code violation over an employee’s personal hygiene.
    For a place to get points off for a worker with poor personal hygiene, they reeaaallly have to not give a fuck.
    The BOH can shut you down; The one day you’d want to scurry the stinky guy out the back door is the day the health department inspector shows up.
    You know how people always secretly worry that the server or someone in the kitchen is doing something disgusting with your food? Coney Island is the only restaurant in the city with a board of health certified dirty person on the payroll, so you probably don’t have to wonder at all about something like that happening. That’s practically a guarantee from the BOH that something gross has already happened to your food, regardless of you being a shitty rude customer.
    I would just as soon burn my tounge right off with a dirty main south heroin cook spoon than eat at Coney Island.
    HDA all the way.

  • Jim
    April 4, 2015 at 1:34 pm

    The famous barbecue sauce at hot dog Annies is an extra charge ($.35 per dog) now and it doesn’t hardly have any onions in it.
    They also don’t use Kayem dogs anymore and when you say where’s the beef, you know you made it to hot dog Annie’s

  • nicke
    April 4, 2015 at 6:42 am

    Turtleboy u r so missing out… u really should try hot dog Annie’s chilli dog vs Connie island chilli dog… Annie’s is bbq Brown sugar base…yummy…my favorite….
    and Connie is more normal chilli base..still good but I need to add ketchup and relish with Connies chilli dogs but so yummy…

    I can’t believe u went there and did not try what both places are known for…the chilli dogs…

    Love ur articles turtleboy u r the man!

  • BobnMic
    April 3, 2015 at 3:13 pm

    I’m starting my own hot dog truck. It’s going to called “Felony Dogs – it’s a crime not to try one. Home of the 12″ dogs where size DOES matter!”

  • leslie
    April 3, 2015 at 11:16 am

    The size of the hot dog is perfect at both places! Barbeque dog at Annie’s, coney dog at Coney island. No comparison!

  • Tasheena
    April 3, 2015 at 10:16 am

    I have to say I like neither. The ones I do like u get a bigger dog on the bun. We’re On a Roll it’s in gold star Blvd home depot parking lot!! Helen who is usually there is a hot sh*t and the dogs r AMAZING!!! Plus u get ur buns toasted!!

  • dstan
    April 3, 2015 at 7:09 am

    ​Nice….I’ve been to both places, HDA’s quite a bit and Coney Island a couple of times.

    Both places are dirty and disgusting. I recall standing at the counter in HDA’s with a freind one day, I was leaning on the counter and noticed that I was slowly sliding backwards. It was the grease on the floor !

    At Coney Island, the place is dark for a reason, so you can’t see the dirt and grime. Those booths are certainly iconic, but they haven’t washed them down in over 50 years. I did like the side of baked beans there (give you ‘the wind’ something fierce).

    You can’t beat the signature barbecue dogs at HDA’s though, mixed heavily with saute’d onions. Plus they use New England style buns and they are toasted, at Coney island they use frankfurter buns like any other New York wanna be joint.

    Plenty of parking at HDA’s, sometimes you can’t find a space near Coney Island.
    You don’t need to lock your car or even roll up the windows at HDA’s.

    I guess it depends on where you are and which place is closer. Either one could kill you with salmonella or at the very least give you a nasty case of the shits.

  • M Dub
    April 3, 2015 at 6:28 am

    I forgot to add:

    at HDA’s there is always the possiblity of catching Hepatitis or Salmonella. Seriously, look at the 3rd picture of HDA’s server making dogs. That counter and serving area is NASTY!

  • M Dub
    April 3, 2015 at 6:23 am

    HDA’s really???? I lost all respect for you Turtleboy. I think we as a city should suspend your Worcester Pass for a few weeks so you can really think your decision over.

    HDA’s = Low Class!
    Doshnoozzles servers with shit attitudes, shit dogs served out of uncovered unheated bins on a dirty counter, a building thats one step up from a Garbage Shed, dirty as parking lot/dining area, broken down picnic tables etc…..

    Coney = High Class!
    Full Bar, Awesome service wih a smile, great sauce, great dogs, served in a beautiful, historic building in Downtown Worcester (YOUR TOWN)

  • GoneWestButNotSoft
    April 2, 2015 at 11:09 pm

    No ones going to point out that Hot Dog Annie’s uses the “New England style” hot dog rolls? Have some pride you savages.

  • Beaver
    April 2, 2015 at 10:56 pm

    What a crock who does this study anyway a horrible comparison like someone stated above you have to do their signature dogs and when you do that they don’t compare they are both delicious it their own right and that’s it I think the only moron in the car on rt 9 that day was you buddy next time why don’t you go compare Arby’s to Burger King and stay on Your level geepahs

    • Factman
      April 3, 2015 at 9:59 am

      Ladies and gentlemen, I give you the worlds longest sentence!

  • David
    April 2, 2015 at 10:27 pm

    Having been to Hot Dog Annie’s many times I can’t help but think the reviewer never went there. Hot Dog Annies doesn’t have chili dogs and the buns are not buttered. By the way, The Dogfather hot dog truck beats Both Coney Island and Hot Dog Annies hands down!!

  • whocareswhoiamorwhatihavetosay
    April 2, 2015 at 10:21 pm

    Coney island wins just for being the closest place to the registry that u can get a beer. B57- estimated wait time 3hours and 42 minutes. Yeah ok see u in 14 beers and 30 hot dogs “up”

  • RJ
    April 2, 2015 at 8:30 pm

    While we’re at it, and I know it’s a truck, but what about the dogfather? Those have to be the best dogs in worcester.

    • BobnMic
      April 4, 2015 at 4:45 pm

      RJ those ARE good dogs. Dogfather uses (what he told me) an award winning chili on his dogs if you order a chili dog. It’s right down the street from where I live and I go to his eminence every Red Sox opening day! I’ll see him next week.

  • Rob
    April 2, 2015 at 8:24 pm

    How about some love for Ronnies in Charlton? Hot dogs and ice cream in one sitting!

    [You missed that Hot Dog Annies has the added benefit of being a short trip to the end of the Worcester airport runway.]

  • Bob!
    April 2, 2015 at 8:22 pm

    I miss Bob’s hotdogs by the reservoir! he was always so nice and those were by far the most superior hot dog I’ve ever had!

  • 4 Up and a chocolate milk
    April 2, 2015 at 8:20 pm

    Nothing will ever beat coney island. 4 up and a chocolate milk for me any day!

  • RJ
    April 2, 2015 at 8:11 pm

    I used to live in Leicester so I’m a little biased, but hot dog Annie’s is the only way to go. I like going to Coney Island if I’m in the area and have nothing better to do, but one time I asked for bbq sauce on my hot dog because, hey, it’s good. They put some weird meat paste on it instead. One of the 6 worst things I’ve ever tasted and one of the 4 most disgusting things I’ve had in my mouth. Never been back.

  • Fattydaddy
    April 2, 2015 at 8:07 pm

    Your opinion; but it’s wrong, first of all you took the picture of Coney with a Hoodie of roll around it compared to Annie’s in which the roll is trimmed back to the dog. I commented Annie’s are the size of a breakfast sausage on FB, but after eating at Bradishes in Grafton they got’em both beat. I like you TB but, maybe you’re not old enough to remember the Old Annie’s or possibly Bob the Hot Dog Man in West Boylston.

    • April 2, 2015 at 8:26 pm

      I was born in 1898!!

      • Finnish Goalie
        April 2, 2015 at 10:12 pm

        You are immortal, and you are not alone.

        • Viever Da Beaver
          April 6, 2015 at 8:00 pm

          Sisu! And Hot Dog Annie’s for the win, Coney Island is sketch AF.

  • George
    April 2, 2015 at 7:27 pm

    We’re talking about hot dogs right? It’s a fuckin hot dog. Don’t get me wrong, I love them. But one guys processed meat, French’s yellow mustard and diced onions are the same as the next guys… been to both. I like both. It’s a fucking hot dog.

  • Medic
    April 2, 2015 at 6:56 pm

    The winner of the Worcester Hot Dog Safari last year was Conie Island And second place by only .3 of a point was We’re on a Roll on Gold star blvd @ the Worcester home depot It has been there for 4 years and has the best dogs by far. not to mention the rest of the menu ….well worth the trip!!

  • Hotdog Champ
    April 2, 2015 at 6:47 pm

    Too bad hot dog express isn’t around anymore, this contest would have been over before it started.

  • Wabbitt
    April 2, 2015 at 6:41 pm

    I’m not American enough, because I don’t like hot dogs. I just don’t go in for the rich flavor of lips and assholes.

    But, I personally prefer the burgers at Annie’s over Coney. But Coney has the better atmosphere and is titty bar adjacent. So it’s basically a wash.

  • Celticgirl
    April 2, 2015 at 6:39 pm

    The better dog can be found at Bradishes in grafton. Foot long dogs toasted buttered bun. Onion rings to die for. Con: only open in the summer

  • m3
    April 2, 2015 at 6:01 pm

    Well TB, it does not happen often but I disagree. I also have to admit that I am a savage. I like my ketchup & onions.

    Hot Dog Annie’s was great once upon a time.

    I will still proudly, I will still wear my TB tee.

  • April 2, 2015 at 6:00 pm

    I don’t live in Mass, so you have me at “I can get drunk there.” Really the only time I eat hot dogs is when I’m drunk watching sports.

    What I want to know is why is this all about pizza and hot dogs? Can’t a brother get some hamhocks and collard greens up in here?


    – Signed “The black guy who doesn’t exist”

    • Devils Mouthpiece
      April 3, 2015 at 10:50 am

      No offense, but what the fuck is a hamhock? Something a pig coughs up when it’s been sniffing another pigs ass??

  • Running to Win
    April 2, 2015 at 5:42 pm

    It has been awhile since I’ve been to either, but I hope to visit both the next time I visit.

  • ihatecops
    April 2, 2015 at 5:42 pm

    Coney island all day. Or Hot Dog Annie in the 70’s-80’s? The new Annies owners fucked that place up. You would never ever order a cheese burger there back then out of fear of one of those tough chick’s to jump the counter and kick your ass. I remember lines half way out the lot. But not now. Coney Island reins supreme!

  • Factman
    April 2, 2015 at 5:24 pm

    Cant wait for the hot dog dump blog tomorrow.

    • April 2, 2015 at 6:02 pm

      Somebody will be thanking God tomorrow for American plumbing.

      • Devils Mouthpiece
        April 3, 2015 at 10:47 am

        This is good shit, LOL – pun not intended.

  • stayghost
    April 2, 2015 at 5:21 pm

    Gotta compare their strengths:

    Annie’s dogs w/ signature BBQ sauce
    Coneys dogs “up”: mustard, onion & meat sauce

  • Not-A-Hippie
    April 2, 2015 at 5:17 pm

    Being in the middle of nowhere compared to the infestation of Worcester is a “pro”, not a “con”.

Comment on this Post


The Big E: Cesspool Of Morons With Infomercials, Fried Dough, And Goat Shit
Mr. And Mrs. Turtleboy Investigate Best Apple Picking In Massachusetts At Tougas Farm Northboro
Leominster Dad Makes Hilarious Vine Compilation Video From Three Months of Saturday Mornings With Kids, Morons Predictably Outraged